Rapidly growing electricity demand — driven largely by data centers — could create serious reliability risks across the state and the broader region unless power supply keeps pace, according to a Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PUC) independent analysis released Sept. 14.
“Pennsylvania is at an energy crossroads,” said PUC Chairman Steve DeFrank. “Data center development brings significant opportunities, but that growth cannot come at the expense of the families and businesses that already depend on reliable and affordable electric service.”
The analysis, conducted by energy consulting firm Synapse Energy Economics, examined whether there will be enough electric resources to reliably serve customers as demand grows and existing generation retires.
The study found that based on current load forecasts from regional power grid operator PJM Interconnection and assuming no additional policy actions, the regional grid fails to meet PJM’s reliability planning standard from 2027 through 2030.
By 2030, in fact, the modeled reliability risk is nearly six times worse than PJM’s planning standard, according to the commission’s study.
“This analysis sends a clear warning: electricity demand and supply are moving out of balance and the status quo is not sustainable,” DeFrank said. “We need urgent action at PJM and a broader Pennsylvania energy strategy that makes sure our supply of electricity keeps pace with demand.”
According to the study, PJM plans the regional electric system around a long-standing reliability standard that aims to limit potential electricity shortages to roughly one event every 10 years.
But, the study says, that risk could change dramatically if electricity demand grows faster than available supply.
For example, under the Reference scenario — which is the most likely scenario based on the current environment — reliability risk in 2030 is nearly six times PJM’s planning standard, the study says.
Under a more severe scenario combining higher electricity demand with constrained development of new generation, the model projects an expectation of more than 13 potential loss-of-load events per year starting in 2030 — compared with the traditional planning standard of one event every decade.
Such results don’t predict that customers will experience a specific number of outages, the study says, “but they illustrate the magnitude of the reliability risk if unprecedented increases in electricity demand significantly outpace the resources available to serve it,” the PUC says.
Data centers are a major factor in the equation.
In the study’s severe scenario, projected new data center demand across PJM between 2029 and 2030 alone exceeds the current annual electricity demand of the entire Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
“The PUC correctly states that the slow pace of new resource entry has reduced supply,” said Pennsylvania Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman (R-41). “While we cannot correct the harm from past decisions by the Executive Branch, we must come together to find ways to support hard-working families across Pennsylvania by making energy more affordable now and in the future.”
The reliability challenge extends beyond Pennsylvania, with PJM’s capacity auctions for both the 2027-2028 and 2028-2029 delivery years falling short of the regional reliability requirement, the study says.
And Pennsylvania’s larger energy challenge can’t be solved by one agency, one report, or one policy initiative, said the commission.
“The PUC will continue doing everything within our authority to protect consumers and reliability, but this issue is bigger than the commission,” DeFrank said. “Pennsylvania’s energy system is changing dramatically, and our energy policies need to evolve with it.
“We need policymakers, regulators, utilities, generators, consumer advocates, and other stakeholders working together on a comprehensive approach that encourages economic growth, brings needed energy resources onto the grid, protects existing ratepayers and preserves reliability,” he said.
Pittman agreed, noting that energy access and affordability go hand-in-hand.
“As we look ahead, we have been clear that all sources of power should be embraced to strengthen Pennsylvania’s power grid,” said the senator, “and I am encouraged the PUC chairman has expressed agreement on this front and wants to ‘put as many watts on the grid as we possibly can.’”
“Time matters,” added DeFrank. “The changes highlighted in this report are not decades away. The reliability pressures emerge during the next several years, and the decisions being made now will determine how prepared we are to meet them.”